More like a standalone set in a shared universe than a sequel, the Girl the Sea Gave Back is set 10 years after the events that took place in a Sky in the Deep. Just like its predecessor, the Girl the Sea Gave Back is beautifully written and immersive. I loved the flashbacks to events that took place in the first book that tied the two together.
Tova is an outsider feared by those around her, used for her ability to foretell the future. Halvard finds himself responsible for his peoples fate at a young age and unsure if he is ready. This book is more about fighting fate, the corruption of power, and wanting better for future generations than warring factions. When the end of the Svell is foretold in the stones they take action to try and fight that fate. By fighting it they actually become the architects of that fate. I loved the juxtaposition between the Svell trying to control fate and Halvard not wanting to know his fate and having it control him and his actions. Those that craved power tried to force fate and only brought about war and destruction, while those that didn’t sought and fostered peace. While the Svell saw Tova as a tool to be used and feared, the Nadhir saw the girl she was. Even the man that raised her only wanted her for the power she had manipulating her to keep that power. When Halvard decides to let the prisoners go picking peace over war and blood feuds it truly shows how beautiful his soul is and how worthy of leading he is.
I feel like there was way more story to be told than what we got. How Tova survived the sea instead of the blanket “fate” explanation would have been great to see. I feel like the climax and resolution where rushed into the last few chapters and we where left with an ending more appropriate for a series than a standalone. Romance was less of a focus and really only came into play the last few pages and isn’t explored in any depth leaving much to be desired on that front.
Overall the Girl the Sea Gave Back is an enjoyable read that explores the dynamics of power and fate, even with the less than satisfying ending.I would love to revisit Adrienne Young’s vikings again in the future.
